Evaluation for the People: An Evolution in How We Learn Together

Innovation Network is evolving. You have heard us talk about equity and paying attention to power dynamics in our evaluations. Now, we are leaning further into a commitment to evaluation for the people: decolonizing evaluation to return it to community hands.

For more than 30 years, Innovation Network has worked alongside communities, organizers, nonprofits, funders, and movements to understand how change happens and how learning can support it. We have seen communities increasingly claim their expertise, evaluation become more intertwined with strategy, and learning evolve beyond accountability reporting toward a shared practice of reflection and action. We have also been evolving ourselves, practicing more community-led approaches, through shared leadership, democratic decision-making, and a deeper commitment to honoring the knowledge and experience within our own organization. More recently, the addition of Co-Director Linda Lu brought new perspectives grounded in feminist and decolonized research.

This strategic shift reflects what we have learned from our history, our partners, and our own practice. We see in our daily work how communities are already generating knowledge every day, in relationships, in lived experience, in storytelling, in reflection, and in the ongoing work of survival and transformation. We believe that evaluation is strongest when it is rooted in community knowledge and collective learning.

We are honoring that knowledge by stepping more fully into what we call liberatory, learning-first evaluation.

Liberatory, learning-first evaluation means…

Knowledge created with communities, defined by communities, and returned to communities in ways that strengthen their power, decisions, and futures. Every evaluation makes choices about what is visible, what is valued, and what becomes action. We are working to shift those choices toward shared authority and community-defined meaning.

From institutional evaluation to community-rooted learning systems

Our core shift is moving from making evaluation more equitable, to reclaiming evaluation as a community-rooted, decolonized, liberatory practice. This shift is not about the types of projects we work on, but shifting our mindsets in two areas:

1. Returning to the truth that learning has always lived in community relationships. Before it became a professionalized field, people were already practicing evaluation by making meaning together, reflecting on new learning, and deciding how to change in response.

We approach evaluation as a living, relational practice of collective sensemaking, while expanding what counts as knowledge. How knowledge is created is as important as what is produced. Story, reflection, lived experience, cultural practice, and quantitative data all sit together in how we understand change.

2. Capacity strengthening as free and accessible to all communities. We believe capacity strengthening should be free. Learning is a core capacity that allows movements and organizations to grow stronger, more responsive, and more rooted in their communities.

Evaluation is too often unevenly distributed and locked behind institutional access. Instead, we hope to treat learning as shared infrastructure, transforming learning into a collective resource that strengthens power. This belief is shaping how we design tools, supports, and learning systems.

Where we are headed: learning systems that build community power

Innovation Network continues to be a small, remote, worker-self-directed nonprofit with decades of experience in evaluation, philanthropy, advocacy, and systems change. We remain committed to quality evaluation, learning for action, and work that furthers social justice.

We are moving toward evaluation as a shared process that communities can use to make decisions, shift resources, and build power. What this looks like in practice:

  • Starting with what communities are already noticing and learning

  • Story, reflection, and lived experience are central forms of evidence

  • Learning is continuous

  • Democratizing evaluation tools, ensuring equal access to learning

  • Shared ownership of data collection, interpretation, and use

We believe our liberation is interconnected, and that real change requires shared infrastructure. We see ourselves as co-creators, working alongside communities, organizers, and funders to build more just, accountable, and community-rooted learning systems.

What’s next: Our learning questions for liberatory evaluation

As part of this evolution, we are in conversation with partners and peers about what it takes to build liberatory evaluation cultures that truly serve communities.

Across the field, we see many people already pushing evaluation in more participatory, relational, community-rooted, and equity-centered directions. We see this moment as an opportunity to learn from one another, deepen existing practices, and continue expanding what evaluation can make possible.

In the coming months, we will be:

  • Researching what learning looks like in constrained nonprofit environments, revitalizing the State of Evaluation we last published in 2016,

  • Exploring how liberatory evaluation is defined and practiced and building community with those committed to it across formal and informal learning roles, and

  • Reimagining evaluation tools to be more accessible and community-owned.

We know meaningful change happens through shared power, collective reflection, experimentation, and solidarity. We also know no single organization or approach holds all the answers. Our hope is to contribute to a broader ecosystem of people who are working to strengthen evaluation as a tool for learning, and community power.

If these areas are alive in your work as well, please reach out to us! We would love to connect and continue learning together.

We are proud to be evolving in this direction, and we are genuinely excited about what this next chapter makes possible in how we (collectively) learn, work, and build alongside communities.

Previous
Previous

Reclaiming the History of Evaluation

Next
Next

Newsletter: Eval, Community, Solidarity